By Sarah Haynes.
Introduction
In Arizona, only the “successful party” in contract-based litigation has the chance to collect their attorneys’ fees from the opposing party. The issue is: how do you define “successful party?”
The Wild West of “Successful Party” Determination
Once upon a time, parties that chose to litigate were always responsible for their own attorney fees. This is known as the American Rule. Today, it is generally accepted that a prevailing party may be awarded their attorney fees, so long as it is provided for by statute or contract. This is known as the English Rule.
In Arizona, under Ariz. Rev. Stat. § 12-341.01(A), “in any contested action arising out of a contract, express or implied, the court may award the successful party reasonable attorney fees.” Other than in the scenario where one party makes a settlement offer and then a later judgment is equal to or less than the original offer, the statute is silent on when a party is the “successful party.” This ambiguity has resulted in substantial litigation challenging a judge’s determination of the “successful party” in a case.
The absence of a statutory definition of “successful party” means determining who the winner is in a case is left to a judge’s discretion. In many cases, this is an easy determination. A case that ends in a final judgment on the merits for only one party has a clear successful party. But what about cases involving counterclaims and mixed rulings for multiple parties? According to Gipson v. Shinnick, courts in Arizona currently have three tests for resolving the issue of determining the successful party in these types of cases: the “net judgment rule,” the “totality-of-the-litigation” test, and the “percentage of success” test.
The “net judgment rule” provides that for cases involving multiple competing and variously successful counterclaims, the party that is the net winner is the successful party. For example, if one party is awarded a twenty-five thousand dollar judgment and the other party is awarded a thirty thousand dollar judgment, the party with the thirty thousand dollar judgment is the net winner by five thousand dollars, so they are deemed the successful party who may be awarded their attorney fees.
Neither the “totality-of-the-litigation” test nor the “percentage of success” test have been formally defined. In American Power Products, Inc. v. CSK Auto, Inc., an appellate case that was vacated on other grounds, the court reasoned that it “determines the prevailing party based on all the circumstances of the case, including the multiple claims made and the parties’ relative success on those claims.” Additionally, the court explained that a party need not completely succeed on its claims to be the successful party, and even a party that is awarded money may not necessarily be the successful party. But this still leaves the “totality-of-the-litigation” test as a shapeless tool for judges to use in exercising their broad discretion, with no real guidelines for application.
The “percentage of success” has seemingly been applied only once, in Pioneer Roofing Co. v. Mardian Construction Co.. There, the court calculated the percentage of damages each party was awarded based on the requested amount of damages, then awarded each party that percentage of their requested attorney fees. This mathematical determination is simple in theory, but its application is so far confined to a case with multiple jury awards. Only additional judicial application of this test can flesh out its bounds.
Of these three tests, only the “net judgment rule” provides a bright-line rule. The determination of the successful party is left to the discretion of the trial court judge and will be upheld so long as there is any reasonable basis to support the judge’s decision. Given the broad guidance provided by the “totality-of-the-litigation” test, it is no wonder that appellate litigation abounds with challenges to trial judges’ discretionary determinations. If Arizona is to mitigate this problem, reform of what has become the Wild West of successful party determinations is necessary.
The Proposed Solution
One rule Arizona could adopt, either legislatively or judicially, is requiring a judicially sanctioned change in the litigating parties’ legal relationship before there can be a successful party. The Supreme Court of the United States found this approach effective in Lackey v. Stinnie last year. Such a rule would require judges to analyze their decisions throughout the case to determine if anything has changed the parties’ respective legal obligations.
No similar determination has ever been made in Arizona, although courts have come close. In Marketech International Corporation USA, Inc. v. Process Service Specialists, L.L.C., the court determined that an award of attorneys’ fees would be “premature” because there had not yet been a decision on the merits. However, such ruling appears inapposite to the finding in Fulton Homes Corp. v. BBP Concrete that “adjudication on the merits is not a prerequisite to recovering attorneys’ fees under A.R.S. § 12-341.01.” Adopting the rule from Lackey v. Stinnie would resolve this conflict. If a judicially sanctioned change in the parties’ legal relationship becomes a necessary prerequisite to determining the “successful party,” then the determinations of Marketech International Corporation and Fulton Homes Corp. would be combined. There would not necessarily need to be a determination on the merits of a case, but there would need to be an adjudication of some sort.
Such a proposition would also help reduce litigation challenging a trial judge’s discretion in naming the successful party. This baseline would give trial judges something concrete to consider in their decision-making before determining a successful party. From there, judges could apply the “net judgment rule” to assess the significance of changes in litigation involving claims and counterclaims.
Conclusion
A party should not qualify as the successful party absent a judicially sanctioned change in the litigating parties’ legal relationship. Arizona does not need to remain the Wild West of “successful party” determinations; the path forward is clear: adopt this bright-line, administrable rule.
Sarah Haynes is a second-year at ASU Law. She holds a bachelor’s degree in Anthropology and a master’s degree in Recreation, Sport, and Tourism Management from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Her academic interests include sport and international law and she hopes to be a litigator. She spent her 1L summer with Dessaules Law Group in Phoenix, AZ. In her free time, she enjoys attempting to learn how to cook. Her proudest accomplishment is her 1,200+ day streak on DuoLingo.